Rooming With My Best Friend - Decisions - Truth - Choose Your Own Story - 2

Truth

Kris looked on with his heart beating faster and Scott rose up with anticipation as the dice slowed down and finally came to a stop with one side facing upwards.

“Truth!” Kris laughed.

“Fucker!” Scott exclaimed. “I had a great dare for you as well.”

“Just shut up and ask me something,” Kris smiled. Part of him was glad to have avoided one of Scott’s dares, but he was also slightly worried about what he might get asked.

“Okay…” Scott said, taking a moment to think. “When me, you and Colt fucked at New Year I couldn’t help but notice something.”

“What?” Kris asked.

“When you fucked me that was exactly what it was… a fuck. It was a way for you to get off that was more fun than just jerking your dick. But when Colt started fucking you, something in you changed. Your body just relaxed into it and there was a look in your eyes that said it meant something more to you than just sex.”

“What’s your point?” Kris asked.

“You love Colt, don’t you?” Scott replied.

Kris chuckled, “Of course I do.”

“No,” Scott said. “I mean actually LOVE him. More than a friend or a buddy…”

“You mean…”

“Are you in love with him?” Scott said, looking directly into Kris’ eyes.

Kris was silent for a moment and he turned his head to look at Colt, who was studying Kris intently. Everyone else in the room was also looking at Kris, waiting for an answer and wondering why it was taking him so long to speak.

“I…” Kris stuttered. “I do love him as more than a friend, yes. We have sex and there’s some greater connection there, which is of a different kind to what I have with anyone else, even Matt, but… no, I don’t think I’m in love with him.”

Kris said nothing else and silence filled the room. No one knew what to say, least of all Colt who still hadn’t taken his eyes off Kris.

“Spin the fucking bottle then, Kris,” Shawn said, wanting to get the game going again.

Kris reached forward and took the bottle into his hand but his mind was elsewhere, feeling as if all eyes were on him still, analysing him and trying to figure out if there was more to his truth than he let on. Hell, he was thinking that himself.

The bottle spun in a rapid circle, coming to a stop on Garrett. Garrett then picked up the dice and rolled it to reveal an S.

“Damn, strip again?” he said, standing up to pull his shirt off. The only two items of clothing he was left wearing were his pants and his tiny briefs, which he didn’t really want anyone to see since he had bought them in the hopes of turning Brennan on so much he couldn’t help himself and would just have to tear them off to get to the real prize underneath.

Garrett then spun the bottle. It landed on Shawn, who rolled the dice, revealing a T.

“Okay, Shawn, truth…” Garrett said, letting the pause linger. “You’re the only person here who hasn’t done anything with a guy. But if you HAD to have sex with one of us, which one would it be?”

“What? I’m not answering that,” Shawn answered.

“Okay then,” Scott said, “take something off if you’re too much of a pussy to answer a hypothetical question.”

“Fuck you! I’m not a pussy!” Shawn protested.

“Answer the fucking question then!” Scott shot back. “It’s not like we’re daring you to bend over the back of the sofa and let him fuck your ass. Garrett just asked which guy you’d do something with if you had no choice but to fuck one of us.”

“Okay…” Shawn said, feeling scolded. “I guess if I had to pick one of you to fuck… it would have to be Colt.”

“Me?” Colt asked surprised. “Why me?”

“Because you’re the straightest one here and I wouldn’t feel too gay if I had to fuck you,” Shawn said.

“I guess that’s fair,” Corey said, “even if you did kind of insult the rest of us.”

“I didn’t mean to,” Shawn said. “I just…”

“Relax. I was messing with ya,” Corey smiled. “Spin the bottle, dude.”

Shawn spun the bottle, which landed on Kris, who still seemed to be off in his thoughts somewhere. When the S appeared he silently removed a shoe and spun the bottle again.

The game continued on with the two most common letters appearing being S and T once again. The questions were becoming less and less probing as the guys struggled to think of interesting, personal questions that could get to some hidden truth or even embarrass the person being asked.

As a consequence of the stripping, Shawn was down to his shorts and boxers, much like Garrett, who so far had managed to avoid having to take anything else off. Kris was left wearing just his boxers and one sock. Matt and Corey both lost their socks, leaving them in shirts, shorts and their briefs. Brennan had lost his shoes and pants, leaving him in his boxers and his socks. Colt had only had to remove his shoes, the rest of his clothes still on. While Scott was cursing himself for removing so many items when he came back from his blowjob dare because he was the closest to being eliminated and was down to his briefs which left nothing to the imagination and showed off almost every inch of his body.

It was Corey’s turn to spin the bottle, having just had to suck beer out of Colt’s belly button on a dare from Shawn. Corey had loved the dare and got carried away, working his tongue all over Colt’s abs, before sucking up the beer and then sliding his tongue in and out of the little hole as if he was fucking it.

“Damn, that was hot,” Brennan said, though he thought he sensed just a hint of jealousy in the looks on Matt and Kris’ faces.

“Matt is one lucky fucker, that’s all I can say,” Colt smiled.

“Hell, yeah, I am,” Matt said, pulling Corey in for a deep kiss.

“Okay, get on with it,” Shawn said.

Corey laughed and reached for the bottle, spinning it and letting go. When it came to stop the neck of the bottle was pointing at Shawn.

Shawn rolled the dice and closed his eyes when he saw it land on D.

“Payback time, bitch,” Corey smiled.

“Fuck…” Shawn muttered under his breath.

“Okay, Shawn…” Corey said, loving the look on Shawn’s face because he was clearly dreading what was coming next. “I want you to crawl over there to Kris, pull his boxers down, and kiss his ass.”

“What?!” Shawn screamed. “I’m not kissing his ass! How fucking gay is that?”

“Your choice, dude, but that means your shorts are coming off,” Corey smiled.

“This isn’t fair. I knew I shouldn’t have played this game with all you gay guys here,” Shawn protested.

“Oh come on, Shawn,” Scott said. “It’s only his ass. Besides, Corey didn’t say you have lick his ass or rim him, you just have to kiss one of his ass cheeks, right Corey?”

“Yep. Or drop your shorts.”

“Fuck!” Shawn exclaimed.

Everyone was watching Shawn, wanting to know what he would do.

Kris was enjoying the sight of Shawn struggling with his decision, having finally left his thoughts behind, his head back in the game. He decided to tease Shawn just a little so he turned around so he was on his hands and knees and pulled his shorts down to reveal his tight, muscular ass.

“Look at that fucking ass!” Garrett breathed, almost moaning.

“It’s a beauty, ain’t it?” Kris asked, wiggling it around.

“Shut the fuck up!” Shawn commanded. “It’s bad enough that I’m thinking about doing this, without you guys making it worse.”

“Just kiss my fucking ass!” Kris teased. “It’s nice and clean so you’re not gonna get anything nasty on your mouth.”

“Here, I’ll do it first to show you it’s no big deal,” Colt smiled, leaning forward to plant a big kiss on Kris’ left butt cheek.

“This is so gay…” Shawn sighed.

“Suck it up, dude,” Kris said.

“That’s just fucking sick, Kris,” Colt joked.

Everyone started laughing and it managed to ease the tension in the room. Shawn shook his head and crawled along the floor, closing his eyes as he leaned forward and placed his lips against Kris’ right ass cheek. He quickly pulled back just as Kris was turning around.

“There, that wasn’t so bad, was it?” Kris asked.

“It could have been worse, I guess,” Shawn conceded.

“Exactly, so spin the bottle and let’s get on with this thing,” Scott said.

Shawn spun and it landed on Garrett. When Garrett rolled the dice he saw the letter that he had been dreading. S.

“Strip!” Colt laughed. “Come on, Garrett, get those shorts off.”

“Fuck!” Garrett exclaimed.

“What?” Kris asked. “We’ve all seen you naked. You’ve got nothing to be ashamed of.”

“I know. It’s just…” Garrett trailed off.

“Just what, babe?” Brennan asked.

“Well, I didn’t know we were going to be playing this game and I kinda hoped we’d be spending the night together, so I dressed for the occasion,” Garrett said quietly.

“Are you wearing panties?” Colt laughed.

“Fuck off!” Garrett laughed back.

“Just take your shorts off. No one cares what you’re wearing underneath. And who knows, you might turn Shawn!” Scott joked.

“In your dreams. I’m the only guy in here you haven’t fucked,” Shawn replied, sticking his tongue out.

“That can change…” Scott smirked.

“No fucking chance!” Shawn chuckled.

“Oh, fuck it!” Garrett said, pushing his shorts down and letting them fall to the floor.

“Holy shit!” Corey exclaimed.

“Damn, bro!” Kris said.

“Hot!” Scott smiled.

“So fucking sexy,” Brennan said. “What the fuck were you worried about?”

Garrett smiled and looked around the room to see all eyes but Shawn’s focused on the tight, baby blue briefs that hugged his big cock in a pouch that was almost too small to contain his flaccid penis. He turned around to hear gasps from the guys when they saw that the material rose rapidly in a V shape, exposing the sides of his ass cheeks, with the fabric cupping his ass, accentuating the shape of each cheek, and disappearing into the crack just enough to tease without being obscene.

Brennan had to reposition himself in his own underwear, “I can’t fucking wait to you get in bed.”

“Now we just need to work on getting more clothes off Colt,” Scott smiled. “He’s wearing far too much.”

“Well, you can’t change how the bottle spins or how the dice rolls, so I guess you just have to come up with a truth I don’t want to answer or a dare I won’t do if you wanna see my ass naked,” Colt smiled.

Garrett spun the bottle and this time it landed between Matt and Corey, resting right in the middle of the two.

“What do we do now?” Garrett asked.

“Either spin it again or they can agree to both do whatever the result of throwing the dice is,” Scott replied.

“What do you think, babe?” Corey asked.

“Do it together?” Matt questioned.

“Works for me. You roll the dice.”

Matt picked up the dice and threw it into the middle of the circle.

“Dare!” Kris exclaimed. “Pick something good that they both have to do.”

“Okay,” Garrett said. “I have no doubt that one of you has cleaned yourself ready for some loving tonight, am I right?”

Matt and Corey looked at each other and then turned back to Garrett.

“Yes, we have,” Matt said, very wary of what was coming.

“Then I dare you both to go out into the hallway,” Garrett said. “One of you has to pull your shorts down and bend over. The other has to slide his dick inside you and fuck you for 60 seconds out there in the hall, and if anyone comes out of their room or up the stairs you have to keep going until the time is up.”

“Holy fuck!” Scott said.

“Shit, man, are you gonna do it?” Kris asked.

“They’ll never do THAT,” Colt said.

Corey looked at Matt, “Why not?”

“Are you serious?” Kris asked.

“I’ve got nothing to be ashamed of, and neither has Matt. I love my boyfriend and I don’t care who knows. Anyway, since we fucked in the classroom we’ve been dying to find new places where we can go at it. It’s exciting,” Corey said.”

Matt blushed, but he stood up nonetheless. “Come on, then,” he smiled, pulling Corey up.

They headed for the door with Kris, Colt, Scott, Brannan and Garrett all jumping up to follow them, not a single one of them believing that Matt and Corey would go through it with. Shawn was the only one who stayed seated, not wanting to see the two guys going at it.

“Are you not even curious?” Colt asked.

“Fuck no,” Shawn replied. “It does nothing for me and I wouldn’t be able to look at the two of them the same again.”

“Your loss,” Colt smiled, turning around to see Corey pulling Matt’s shorts down as they stood in the middle of the hallway.

Corey got down on his knees and quickly started licking Matt’s asshole, wanting to get it wet before he shoved his thick cock inside him. He then stood up, after tongue fucking Matt for almost 30 seconds, and spat into his hand, rubbing it all over his dick as lube.

“I can’t believe they’re doing this,” Garrett said. “Even when I set the dare I never dreamed they’d go through with it. I was trying to get them both to strip.”

“You should know by now that when it comes to us you can never say we’re predictable,” Scott smiled.

“Oh fuck…” Matt groaned as Corey pushed his dick inside him. The friction from the bare cock, only covered in a thin layer of saliva was intense and he had to bite his lip to stop himself from screaming with a mixture of both pleasure and pain.

Garrett had his phone in hand and opened the stop watch application. “Are you all in, Corey?”

“Nearly,” Corey replied, through clenched teeth, feeling Matt’s ass squeeze him so tight.

“Okay, in three… two… one… FUCK!” Garrett called.

Corey put his hands on Matt’s hips and started thrusting his thick cock in and out of his hot boyfriend. They were both trying their best not to make too much noise as the sensations flowed through their bodies and Corey’s hips started slamming into Matt’s ass, creating slapping sounds.

Suddenly a door just down the hall opened and a voice called out, “I’m just going down to the store… What?”

All eyes were looking down the hallway to where the voice came from while Corey was still fucking Matt’s ass. The door closed again as the female whose voice it was went back inside.

The excitement was almost too much for Corey and he felt himself getting close, even though it had only been 45 seconds. He fucked Matt even harder, who couldn’t help but groan, his own hard dick bouncing around between his legs as he leaned forward and braced himself on his knees.

“10… 9… 8… 7… 6… 5… 4… 3… 2… 1… Stoooop fucking!” Garrett called.

Just then the door opened again. Corey quickly pulled his dick out of Matt and they both pulled up their shorts as the girl stepped out into the hallway. They smiled at her and she looked at them curiously but then just kept walking. As soon as she was in the stairwell they all ran back inside the room.

“Holy fuck!” Kris shouted. “I can’t believe you actually fucking did that shit.”

“Damn man…” Corey panted. “That was so fucking tense… My heart is pounding harder… than it ever has in the Rec… It really got the adrenaline pumping… and nearly had my dick pumping in Matt’s ass!”

“Matt?” Scott asked. “You okay?”

“That was insane,” Matt breathed, but then he started laughing, “but so fucking hot!”

“Hell, yeah, it was,” Corey agreed. “We’re doing that shit again sometime.”

All the friends laughed and joined Shawn, who was still sitting in his previous position in the circle. Matt and Corey leaned forward, placing their hands on top of the bottle. Looking at each other and nodding they spun it.

“Scott!” Corey smiled.

Scott picked up the dice and threw it into the middle of the circle.

“FUCK!” Scott screamed.

“Strip, dude,” Colt grinned.

“I can’t believe I’m the first one out,” Scott said. “I never should have taken those extra layers off when I came back.”

“Just quit your whining and get those sexy little briefs off,” Colt smiled.

Scott stood up and started rotating his hips, doing a little strip tease as he ran his hand over his tight body, moving over his pecs, down his abs, until his hand slid into his briefs and he pushed them down, turning around to wiggle his ass for all to see.

“Okay, we get the idea, you’re hot with an amazing ass, now sit down,” Corey laughed.

“What happens now you’re eliminated?” Brennan asked. “Can you still spin the bottle?”

“No,” Scott said. “I have to spin the bottle to choose my replacement, then I step out and you guys continue.”

“Oh, okay,” Brennan said.

Scott spun the bottle and it landed on Kris.

“So I’m spinning the bottle, right, not rolling the dice?” Kris asked.

“Exactly,” Scott agreed.

“Cool,” Kris said, spinning the bottle. It landed on Colt.

Colt rolled the dice and came up with his least common letter, S. He smiled and looked around the room. “I’ll even things up a little,” he said, pulling both socks off.

Colt then spun the bottle and the game continued. Garrett and Shawn both quickly lost their remaining clothes and joined Scott in sitting up on one of the sofas, naked. Kris, Matt, Corey and Brennan were all down to their underwear, while Colt had stripped off his shorts, leaving him with his boxers and his shirt still on.

It was Colt’s turn to spin again when it landed on Kris, who in turn rolled a D.

“I dare you to go down to Ted’s room, get down on your knees, knock on the door, and then when whoever is inside opens it, you have to open your mouth and offer to suck their dick,” Colt smiled.

“Are you fucking mad?” Kris asked.

“Do it or get naked,” Colt said.

“Fine!” Kris exclaimed, reaching down to pull off his boxers. “No way in Hell am I doing that dare.”

“Sweet Jesus,” Colt said. “I finally managed to break Kris and found something he won’t do.”

Kris just shook his head, annoyed that his game had ended the way it had. He grabbed a beer and joined the other guys who had been eliminated in watching the rest of the game play out.

Brennan was quickly eliminated, having to take off his boxers, quickly followed by Matt, who gave Corey a kiss and told him to beat Colt.

Since it was down to the final two they stopped spinning the bottle and just rolled the dice. On the next roll Colt lost his shirt, meaning both he and Corey were down to their boxers and briefs respectively. Whoever rolled the next S or chickened out of a question or dare would lose, with his opponent being the victor.

Corey rolled a T and let out a sigh of relief.

Colt smiled and cocked his head to the right, “Are you still jealous of Matt and Kris and think Matt’s gonna leave you so they can be together as lovers?”

“No,” Corey replied almost instantly.

“Really? Because when we roomed together last semester you said you thought Matt was in love with Kris and you were terrified that once Kris realised his true feelings Matt would leave you for him,” Colt replied.

“That’s low, Colt. I’m not worried in the slightest. Kris has moved on. I’m not worried about him stealing MY boyfriend, Colt, but I am worried about him stealing Andrea’s.”

“What the fuck, Corey?” Kris protested.

“Stay out of this, Kris,” Colt and Corey both said together.

“Roll the dice, Colt,” Corey added.

Colt picked up the dice and threw it across the floor. The smile on Corey’s face couldn’t have been bigger.

“FUCK!” Colt shouted. “I knew I shouldn’t have taken both socks off.”

He stood up and pulled his boxers off, throwing them at Corey’s face.

“Corey wins!” Scott proclaimed.

“Now I’m gonna claim my prize and go fuck my hot boyfriend for real, finish off what I started earlier,” Corey smiled.

He pulled Matt to him for a long kiss and then walked toward their bedroom, taking Matt with him.

“I guess we’d better be going too,” Brennan said. “It’s getting late.”

“It’s been a great night though,” Scott said. “You guys don’t mind me being in the room tonight, do you?” he asked Brennan and Garrett as they put their underwear back on and headed for the door with Shawn behind them.

“Nah, man, we might even let you join in,” Garrett smiled.

“Just keep the fucking screams down,” Shawn laughed and they all left, closing the door.

“What about you, bro?” Kris asked. “What are you doing tonight?”

“Andrea wanted me to go down to her room for the night after we finished since her roommate isn’t there, but she told me not to bother if it got too late, and it’s well after one now. I’m not sure if she’ll still be up,” Colt said, debating whether or not to text her to see if she was still awake.

“Well, I’m clean tonight and am happy to give you the sex she would, so decide what you want, bro,” Kris said. “I’ll be in our room. When you’ve made up your mind either come join me, or I’ll see you in the morning.”

Colt watched as Kris walked away from him, the amazing muscle ass bouncing up and down. Colt could so easily fuck that, but he had a girlfriend waiting for him in a room down the hall.

Where does Colt go? You decide.

If you want Colt to go to into his room, click here: To Kris (Chapter 04)

If you want Colt to go to Andrea’s room, click here: To Andrea (Chapter 05)